These Are The Best Pizza Places To Try Out In Sheffield

There’s nothing like a delicious slice of pizza. That warm and fluffy feeling you get after a beautiful, cheesy slice is unbeatable – and what’s better? Finding a new restaurant that serves up something real special. To help you find your one true pairing, we’ve rounded up a list of the best pizza in Sheffield.

Proove Pizza, Broomhill

Credit: Proove Pizza

A strong contender for the best pizza in Sheffield, Proove Pizza was born in Broomhill and has been loved by authentic Neapolitan pizza fans ever since. The restaurant does things the Italian way, using double zero flour which is proved for a minimum of 20 hours – delivering delicious, doughy pizzas that are finished off with the perfect ‘leopardo cornicione’ crust that Neapolitan pizzas are renowned for.

If you’re looking for a taste of authentic Italy, Proove Pizza knows just how to do it. Proove, 261 Fulwood Rd, Sheffield, S10 3BD.

Craft & Dough, Kelham Island

Credit: Craft & Dough

Kelham Island’s Artisan pizza spot is a popular one for craft beer lovers, with pizza and other Italian dishes available to order.

The spot is great to pick up a deal too, with monthly offers usually available to take advantage of. Pizzas ring in at less than a tenner, with so many toppings to choose from. Topping highlights include tandoori chicken, pulled pork with bacon and braised beef with pepperoni. Not only that, guests can also upgrade their dough to a garlic brushed crust for just 50p – a nice unique touch for garlic bread lovers! Craft and Dough, 1A Kelham Square, Kelham Island, Sheffield, S3 8SD.

Baked In Brick, Kommune, City Centre

Credit: Baked In Brick

Birmingham born Baked In Brick is a street food highlight, popping up at the city centre’s Kommune. The pizza makers are pretty innovative, utilising their hand-built wood-fire pizza oven built into the front of a classic Mini, with a BBQ under the bonnet.

The pizza makers aren’t just a novelty, however, with multiple awards under their belts for their delicious street food. The vendors are well known for their BBQ chicken tikka wraps, but as well as that, they throw up a delicious Neapolitan pizza. Baked In Brick have a ton of pizza options available, with two vegan options currently available for vegan pizza fans. Kommune, Castle House, Angel St, Sheffield, S3 8LS.

Napoli Centro, Broomhill

Credit: Napoli Centro

If the crusts haven’t sold you already, Napoli Centro is one of Sheffield’s greatest pizza restaurants – serving up traditional Neapolitan style pizzas with incredible leopardo cornicione crusts. For novices, the black spots on the crust are a tell-tale sign of a great Naples-worthy pizza!

Situated in Broomhill, the independent traditional pizzeria source all of their ingredients from Campania itself, with slow proofed dough cooked at 500 degrees for just 90 seconds creating their perfect, fluffy signature pizzas that’ll have you begging for more. I’m drooling just thinking about it. The pizzeria prides itself on being authentically Italian, and is well worth the visit for a taste of Naples in Sheffield. Napoli Centro, 343 Glossop Rd, Sheffield, S10 2HP.

Nether Edge Pizza, Nether Edge

Credit: Nether Edge Pizza

Rating itself as Sheffield’s ‘finest’ pizzeria, Nether Edge has two spots serving up wood-fired pizza – one in Kelham Island, and one in Nether Edge itself.

The guys behind Nether Edge are passionate about pizza and they really love what they do – which is evident after just one taste of their pizza! Their award winning wood-fired pizzas come with a ton of topping options including all the usual traditional Italian treats, jerk chicken, calabrese, BBQ jackfruit and many more. The restaurant offers both dine-in and takeaway options, as well as an outdoor seating area and Italian lager to wash it all down with. Nether Edge Pizza, 144 Abbeydale Rd, Sheffield, S7 1FF.

The Porter Pizza Company, Sharrow

Credit: The Porter Pizza Company

Making Italian inspired pizzas, The Porter Pizza Company sits just on the outskirts of Sheffield and cooks up delicious pizzas using authentic Italian ingredients in their wood-fired oven.

Considering themselves as a restaurant with ‘integrity’, Porter Pizza use a similar baking method to other Neapolitan style pizzerias – making sure to get that beautiful spotty crust for a traditional Italian finish. They even do collection if you fancy enjoying it in the comfort of your own home. The Porter Pizza Company, 410 Sharrow Vale Rd, Sheffield, S11 8ZP.